What Is a Memoir? The Difference Between Personal Memory and Historical Record 

Bart A. Charlow Author - Oct. 22, 2026

What exactly is a memoir, and who has the authority to write one? History attempts to establish what happened; memoir explores what it was like to live through it. Growing up as a third-generation Catskills hotel family member gave me a firsthand perspective on the Borscht Belt—one that differs from the stories told by its guests, entertainers, and historians.

People often confuse memoir with academic history; it’s not! Nor is it quite an autobiography, though many memoirs are autobiographical.

So what is it?

Think of it as a snapshot of something significant in the life of the writer, or something historically interesting that the writer experienced personally. It’s non-fiction, though it may read with some of the drama, tension and description of the best of fiction.

A memoir is “true”, but not necessarily precisely accurate factually, because it's based on imperfect human memories, though not inventions. Now I’m probably really confusing you.

History portrays accurate facts – or at least as they are known and agreed to broadly. On this date that person did something, and there’s general consensus that it happened that way.

Memoir, by contrast, starts with the word “me”.

It’s the truth from an individual’s standpoint, how they experienced something, though it may not be 100% factually accurate, and others may have experienced it quite differently. It’s their truth, not everyone’s, and that’s what makes it interesting.

History is generally dry. A memoir cannot ever afford to be.

When I wrote my memoir, A Catskill Carnival, the subtitle told it all: “My Borscht Belt Life Lived, Lost and Loved”. My truth from the viewpoint of a third generation hotel person, a “hotel brat” growing up in the middle of all that tumult, and how I came to view it differently at various ages.

How I viewed that world is different from the guests, the paid staff, and even my family members, not to mention the other hotel brats with their own fiefdoms and stories.

But it is my truth, and I wrote it to be as engaging and entertaining as I would have told you over a drink on a long evening.

Most accounts of or tributes to the Borscht Belt glorify the entertainment, and indeed that was a very big part of its richness. That was far from all of what drew millions to the Catskill hotels and bungalows. There was an entire culture, a seminal period of Jewish-American history that still influences much of resort style and American culture today.

All that is true and I do give credit to it in my talks about the era. But my books are written to show the inside stories, the heartache, the headaches and the head scratching characters that made it so vibrant at the level that real people knew – not just the rich or famous.

I believe firsthand experience matters. The history of a place is often told through its most visible people and events. In the Catskills, that means the famous entertainers, the grand hotels, the comedians, and the legendary summer entertainment scene. But the people who lived and worked there experienced an entirely different world: family obligations, seasonal rhythms, financial pressures, personal relationships, and the daily comedy and frustration of running a resort.

Those experiences are part of the historical record too, even if they don't always make it into the history books. That is the perspective I wanted to preserve in my own memoirs.

So when you reach for my books, you will find that “me” in the memoirs, but if you were there, you’re likely to find a bit of yourself as well.

If you want to step behind the curtain of mid-century Catskills resort culture—beyond the headliners and into the daily lives of the families who ran them—explore my two memoirs, A Catskill Carnival and Pickle Barrel Tales.