Why Humans Keep Creating: Art, Storytelling and the AI Age 

Bart A. Charlow Author – Sep. 28, 2026

Artificial intelligence is changing the world of art, writing, photography, and other creative professions. But will it ever replace the human need to create? From prehistoric cave paintings to contemporary novels and paintings, the impulse to tell stories and leave something of ourselves behind has endured for thousands of generations. A reflection on technology, creativity, and what makes us human.

I'm not wading into the question du jour: "Is AI art?" I plan to tackle that down the road.

But considering that the AI train has left the station, another big question today is whether creatives are being railroaded by it. The issue is broadly spread across so many artistic mediums: painting, photography, filmmaking, writing, performance arts, etc.

According to a Sep. 27, 2026 article in Apricitas Economics, the answer appears to be mixed.

There is some good analysis here regarding determining how AI is impacting creative industries and jobs. The picture is overlaid with the complication that changes in audience preferences as to how they consume artistic works also have very great impact on creative occupations. In some cases it's made only a shift; in others the analysis suggests AI is killing some professions.

Recently I read my novel at an authors’ event at Twin Pines Manor in Belmont. Most of the small audience were writers or creators themselves. The still reading public seemed either unaware or uninterested in leaving their screens or couches to attend a night event, though book sales are reported to show an upward trend (while the number of readers show a downward one.)

Here's what strikes me: The Arts as professions are undergoing a massive, rapid change and it's not a pretty sight for anyone hoping to make a paying career of it. On the other hand, people creating is far from receding. It's such a human compulsion, documented at least 100,000 years in our existence, and I see no loss of that impulse.

There are really two different questions here, and I think they often get confused. One is whether technology can produce something that looks or sounds like a work of art. Clearly it can, and the capabilities are advancing rapidly. The other is whether technology can replace the human impulse that causes someone to create in the first place. That is a very different proposition. People don't paint, write, perform, or tell stories solely because they expect to earn a living from it. They do it because they have something they want to express, communicate, explore, or leave behind.

For countless generations human beings have been presenting their thoughts in so many mediums. Cave carvings and paintings are not just visual art; rather, they are also documentaries that predate and evolved into writing.

The earliest surviving examples of human artistic expression are remarkable not simply because of their age, but because they demonstrate that people wanted to communicate something beyond the immediate necessities of survival. The images on cave walls suggest observation, imagination, shared experience, and perhaps storytelling. We cannot know exactly what every image meant to its creator, but the impulse to make a mark and communicate something to others is unmistakable.

That impulse has taken countless forms since then. The materials have changed, the audiences have expanded, and the technology has become almost unimaginable to those early artists. But the desire to create has remained.

Those colorful images, those repetitive scratches on rock and bone, are actually stories. Some tell of the hunt, some of the animals and their environment, some appear to be counting predating numbers, and some may even be depictions of time by noting the phases of the moon. Speculation about animal-masked human forms suggest ritual performances.

In other words, the full spectrum of creative endeavors we call “The Arts” before technology expanded them.

I find this particularly interesting because I work in two very different creative mediums. As a painter, I interpret what I see and experience visually. As a novelist, I do much the same thing with people, relationships, memory, and imagination. Neither activity is simply about producing an object. It is about trying to communicate something that might otherwise remain inside one's own head.

That's the part of creativity I don't believe technology can make obsolete.

And now this new technology is threatening to replace all of that – at least the human part.


Perhaps we will get lazy as to how we still create. Or more likely new ways to create will continue to appear. But we will not STOP creating, even as AI and whatever comes next makes living off the proceeds increasingly dim.


So it's entirely possible that "The Terminator" is in our future, but I feel confident we will still scratch graffiti on the walls of our hidey holes! 


​Even as technology reshapes how stories are shared, nothing replaces the deeply human connection between a lived experience and the page—a conviction that drives every word of my novels, That Catskill Summer and This Never Should Have Happened.