Why I Hand-Painted My Novel's Cover: Art, Identity and Book Marketing 

Bart A. Charlow Author - May 7, 2026

Why would an author choose to hand-paint his own novel cover rather than follow prevailing romance-publishing trends? As both a novelist and a lifelong artist, I wanted the cover of That Catskill Summer to convey the story's emotional depth, its Catskills setting, and its distinctive characters—not simply follow the marketplace.

You've all heard the old saw, "You can't judge a book by its cover." Totally wrong when it comes to actual books! Anyone in the business will tell you that the very first thing that sells a book (other than a direct recommendation) is its cover. Bar none, end of story, that's all she wrote (except for the cover blurbs.)

In choosing a cover for any of my books I feel strongly that the cover needs to be more than just inviting, it needs to hint at the story within. My two non-fiction books, A Catskill Carnival and Pickle Barrel Tales, both feature views of the Hotel Irvington of my youth, one a vintage postcard, the other a watercolor sketch of my own. Each hints at what's inside. For Carnival it's a history, a very personal one. For Pickle it's humorous sketches, literally true in both senses of that word.

So when it came to my debut novel, That Catskill Summer, I followed the same path and I do like the result. That cover is a composite of elements of the story. The largest is a couple embracing, since it's a love story of some depth. A vintage touring car and a hotel frontage are the next elements, as they depict the setting. A small professional video camera is the last element, indicating that there's some filming involved. From those icons you get a sense of the story line.

For me, a book cover is a form of visual storytelling. It has to do more than attract attention in a crowded marketplace; it should establish an expectation about the experience awaiting the reader. In the case of That Catskill Summer, the combination of the embracing couple, the vintage hotel setting, and the camera hints at a story that moves between past and present. The painting is therefore not decoration added after the writing. It is another way of telling the story.

More importantly, the style was a key factor, since covers sell the book, I needed a style that has marketing power. In romance novels there used to be the realistic old style painting, often with the male model Fabio showing his physique, or alternately a woman in such a man’s passionate embrace looking swept into another galaxy. That style was supplanted by more photo-realistic versions of the same thing. For the past 5 years or so romance covers changed markedly to a cartoonish style with barely noticeable facial features and bright colors. That's what's selling books like hotcakes right now.

As reported in 2025, around four million titles are published annually, 2.5M of them brand new. The market is so oversaturated as to be ridiculous. So how would my book cover stand out?

The key for me was in that phrase, "stand out". It had to be the same in essence, but different enough to show a distinction.

So what I did, being an artist, was to select those key elements, find models that fit the visual there, and hand sketch and paint my own stylistic versions. Not cartoonish, but sketchy. Not photo-realistic, but accurate enough.

Voila!

I did test variations on this theme, BTW, trying out an AI rendering from my painting. Most in my test group found my own style distinctive, informative, interesting, fun - and easily distinguishable from AI. It seems to be working from market response so far.

Every element on that cover—the embracing couple, the vintage touring car, the hotel frontage, and the camera—was chosen to reflect the layered, dual-timeline love story inside. You can learn more about the story and explore the book on my That Catskill Summer page.